Henny Wiley is a widowed hoarder who lives with her husband's ghost. The only thing she enjoys more than a good yard sale is a good dumpster dive. When she finds her latest treasure—a ceramic angel— she knows just who to bring it to.

Jenna Lawson is a cashier at the Blue Market convenience store where Henny often shops. The two women have formed a strong bond to assuage the losses in their lives, and Henny thinks of Jenna like the daughter she lost long ago. So, when Jenna goes missing, Henny is determined to find out what happened to her.

As she works to unravel the mystery, a man at church, Neville Miller, shows interest in Henny, leading her to wonder if the lonely days are finally coming to an end. But her ghostly husband, Walter, sure isn’t going to like it.

Henny is on a hunt that may claim the ultimate price—her own life.